Sybil Exposed

Starred review from September 19, 2011
Journalist Nathan (Satan’s Silence) has spent much of her career writing about child sex abuse panics and debunking “recovered memory syndromes,” in which adults—aided by over-zealous therapists—suddenly “recalled” episodes of childhood abuse. Here, she tackles one of the most famous of these cases: that of the multiple-personality sufferer known to the world as “Sybil”—the subject of the 1970s bestseller and a TV special starring Sally Field and Joanne Woodward (who starred in Three Faces of Eve, an earlier film of multiple personality). In this startling exposé, she examines the records author Flora Rheta Schreiber left with the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, detailing Schreiber’s research into the unusual case of the frail, troubled Shirley Mason—the real Sybil. The extensive therapy transcripts reveal that Mason’s psychiatrist, Dr. Connie Wilbur, may have cued “memories” of horrific childhood abuse during marathon hypnotherapy and electroshock sessions supplemented with mind-altering drugs. Nathan traces the paths of the three women—the patient, the doctor, and the author who publicized the case—who formed “Sybil Incorporated.” Along the way, she reasons that the concept of the multiplicity of selves—and the subsequent popularity of the diagnosis—may have become the perfect idiom of distress for a generation of women who, rocked by the feminist revolution, felt confusion at their new and conflicting roles. Leveling a steady eye on her oft-sensationalized subject, Nathan serves up a tale just as shocking as the famed original.

April 30, 2012
Made famous by the publication of Flora Rheta Schreiber’s Sybil, Shirley Mason (aka Sybil) allegedly possessed 16 unique personalities, a condition for which she was treated by psychoanalyst Cornelia Wilbur. This book by Nathan suggests that Mason may have been far less disturbed than initially reported—and that, in fact, her “illness” was the product of a collaborative fabrication, dreamed up by Wilbur, Schreiber, and Mason herself. Marguerite Gann provides this audio edition with strong, declarative narration that suits the thorny subject matter. When inhabiting one of Mason’s personalities or capturing the fraught relationship between Mason, Wilbur, and Schreiber, the narrator shines, varying her vocal tone and creating significant drama. However, during more straightforward passages, Gann’s performance is markedly less compelling. Still, this is a fascinating audiobook that will interest listeners fascinated with the human psyche. A Free Press hardcover.